Do you have a physical store?

We do NOT have a physical store, we are fully operating online via our website, instagram and etsy! We work out of our home in Sleepy Hollow, NY. We plan to have pop ups throughout the year. Make sure to follow us on social media to stay updated on where you can find our stuff!

How long will it take for my order to ship?

Most apparel orders are fulfilled and shipped by our printing partner within 3–5 business days, and sometimes sooner! Please note that orders typically do not ship out on weekends. During peak season, processing and shipping times may take a little longer. Thank you for your patience! Souvenirs like magnets, postcards, and stickers ship directly from us. If your order includes both apparel and souvenirs, your items will most likely arrive in separate packages, each with its own tracking.

Are any of your items available for purchase in Sleepy Hollow or Tarrytown?

Currently, all our items are available exclusively online. However, we have exciting plans for the future! We're planning pop-up events and collaborations with local businesses. To stay updated on our latest news and events, make sure to follow us on Instagram and like our Facebook page!

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thehorsemans_shop/

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/OfficialHorsemansShop

Do you accept returns/offer refunds?

Due to the made-to-order nature of our items, we do not offer refunds or accept returns or exchanges once an order has been placed, except in cases where the item arrives damaged or has a manufacturing error. If you receive a damaged item or encounter any issues, please contact us so that we can assist you and provide a suitable resolution.

Are your products made in-house?

While we don’t personally handle the production and shipping of most of our items, we work with a trusted, US-based printing provider to ensure top quality. As a small business, this allows us to focus on the creative aspects—like coming up with new designs, managing our social media, and running our website. Every design starts as our own idea, inspired by the places, stories and legends we grew up with in Sleepy Hollow. We work with talented artists to bring those ideas to life, and we never use pre-made designs. Our goal is to offer exclusive and authentic products that capture the spirit of Sleepy Hollow for both tourists and locals alike!

I have a question, what is the best way to reach you?

The best way to reach us will be via email! You can also shoot us a quick DM on instagram. Please note that we will always try to provide a prompt response via email but keep in mind, we all have full time jobs apart from The Horseman’s Shop so at times you may receive a response after 5:30pm EST.

What happens if I don't receive my package but the tracking says "delivered"?

If the carrier marks your package as delivered, but you haven't received it, we recommend reaching out to the carrier directly to inquire about any additional details or instructions left by the delivery person. In certain cases, we may be able to assist you by replacing your order, but please note that you would be responsible for covering the cost of shipping.

What if my order is simply lost in the mail?

In the rare event that your order is lost in transit, please reach out to us as soon as possible. We will work with you to resolve the issue and arrange for a replacement to be sent at no additional cost.

Are there going to be any additional items available for purchase?

YES! There are many additional items in the works including some additional apparel options with new designs, new souvenirs, drinkware, and more!